EC Psychology And Psychiatry

Masturbation with pornographic material in prison. The blanket prohibition on introducing pornographic material into prisons in Israel as well as in other places, is not grounded in substantive considerations but instead rests on archaic and/or conservative worldviews. allowing inmates access to pornographic material for the purpose of masturbation may reduce rates of violence in general, and rape in particular, by improving the physical and mental health of the prison population [2]. The article examine four core questions: (1) whether masturbation with pornographic material constitutes a fundamental right protected under freedom of expression; (2) whether permitting conjugal visits for partnered inmates while prohibiting solitary sexual expression for single, separated, or divorced inmates violates the right to equality; (3) whether denying prisoners the ability to masturbate with the aid of pornographic material infringes upon their physical and mental health; and (4) whether the introduction of pornography into prison presents a meaningful risk to inmate conduct and institutional security, as prison administrators claim, or whether this assertion lacks empirical support.

 Keywords: Prisoners; Sexual Privacy; Pornography; Masturbation; Conjugal Visits; Prison Law; Israel Prison Service; Human Rights

1. Birnhack MD. “Holes in the net: Pornography, information, and policy design in the digital environment”. Politika 13 (2005): 101-125.
2. Carcedo RJ., et al. “Sexual satisfaction and mental health in prison inmates”. Journal of Clinical Medicine5 (2019): 705.
3. Chan HC. “Case 08 - The London Muswell Hill murderer: The case of Dennis Andrew Nilsen (1978-1983; UK)”. In H. C. Chan (Ed.: A global casebook of sexual homicide), Springer (2019): 125-140.
4. Dworkin R. “Is there a right to pornography?” Oxford Journal of Legal Studies2 (1981): 177-212.
5. Eaton NR., et al. “Pornography consumption, modality and function in a large internet sample”. Journal of Sex Research1 (2018): 95-103.
6. Ferguson CJ and Hartley RD. “The pleasure is momentary…the expense damnable?: The influence of pornography on rape and sexual assault”. Aggression and Violent Behavior5 (2009): 323-329.
7. Gaillard A. “Emotional despair and restrained desires”. Max Milo (2023).
8. Goffman E. “The characteristics of total institutions”. In M. Lisak (Ed.: Issues in sociology: Social structure and stratification: A reader, Am Oved (1976): 264-303.
9. Good E. “Deviant behavior (10^th edition)”. Prentice Hall (2015).
10. Hayner NS. “Attitudes toward conjugal visits for prisoners”. Federal Probation1 (1972): 43-49.
11. Hopper CB. “Sex in prison: The Mississippi experiment with conjugal visiting”. Louisiana State University Press (1969).
12. Hughes SD. “Release within confinement: An alternative proposal for managing the masturbation of incarcerated men in U.S. prisons”. Journal of Positive Sexuality1 (2020): 4-23.
13. Marashi SA. “A theory on the nonlinear relationship of sexual behavior and aggression”. Iranian Journal of Psychiatry4 (2024): 453-462.
14. McKee A. “Understanding pornography in Australia”. Eros Journal3 (2002): 1-21.
15. Mellor E and Duff S. “The use of pornography and the relationship between pornography exposure and sexual offending in males: A systematic review”. Aggression and Violent Behavior 46 (2019): 116-126.
16. Miller DJ., et al. “A literature review of studies into the prevalence and frequency of men’s pornography use”. American Journal of Sexuality Education4 (2020): 505-529.
17. Mineka S., et al. “Abnormal psychology and modern life (10^th edition)”. Addison Wesley Longman (1998).
18. Mordechai N., et al. “A guide for the legislator”. The Israel Democracy Institute (2015).
19. Napoli LA. “Demystifying “pornography”: Tailoring special release conditions concerning pornography and sexually oriented expression”. The University of New Hampshire Law Review1 (2013): 69-95.
20. Narkis S. “Prisoners' rights - law and jurisprudence”. Otzar HaMishpat (2008).
21. Rivlin R. “Pornography: Morality, liberty, equality: A proposal for amending the prohibition on publishing and displaying obscenity and related offences”. The Israel Democracy Institute (2003).
22. Rosenpler S. “Prisoners, guards, and what lies between them: Maasiyahu Prison, 1978-1982”. Zvi Einat (2004).
23. Seto MC., et al. “The role of pornography in the etiology of sexual aggression”. Aggression and Violent Behavior 1 (2001): 35-53.
24. Shoham SG., et al. “Offences and punishments: An introduction to penology”. Ach Ltd (2009).
25. Smith BV. “Rethinking prison sex: Self-expression and safety”. Columbia Journal of Gender and Law 15 (2006a): 185-234.
26. Smith BV. “Analyzing prison sex: Reconciling self-expression with safety”. Human Rights Brief3 (2006b): 17-22.
27. Sykes MG. “The society of captives”. Princeton University Press (1958).
28. Tewksbury R and West A. “Research on sex in prison during the late 1980s and early 1990s”. The Prison Journal4 (2000): 368-378.
29. Toch H. “Mosaic of despair: Human breakdowns in prison”. American Psychological Association (1992).
30. Vronsky P. “Serial killers: The method and madness of monsters”. Penguin Books (2004).
31. Yakir D. “Conjugal visits for same-sex prisoner couples”. Association for Civil Rights in Israel (2009).
32. [Hebrew].
33. Israeli Legislation, Regulations and Orders.
34. Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty, 5752-1992.
35. Conjugal Visits of Prisoners or Detainees with Their Partners, Commissioner’s Order of 1 August 2001.
36. Prison Regulations, 5738-1978.
37. Israeli Case Law.
38. HCJ 73/53 Kol Ha’am Co. Ltd. v. Minister of Interior, PD 7(2) 871 (1953).
39. HCJ 221/80 Darwish v. Israel Prison Service, PD 35(1) 536 (1980).
40. HCJ 114/86 Haim Louis Weil v. State of Israel, PD 41(3) 477 (1987).
41. CA 4/82 (BS 904/82) State of Israel v. Tamir, PD 37(3) 201 (1983).
42. RPF 2410/93 State of Israel v. Levi, PD 47(3) 802 (1993).
43. HCJ 4804/94 Station Film Co. Ltd. v. Film Review Board, PD 50(5) 661 (1997).
44. RPF 2529/97 State of Israel v. Ozen (1997).
45. RPF 6944/96 State of Israel v. Kuntar., et al. PD 50(4) 492 (1996).
46. HCJ 5304/15 Israeli Medical Association v. Knesset of Israel (2016).
47. HCJ 1892/14 Association for Civil Rights in Israel v. Minister of Internal Security (2017).
48. HCJ 4386/16 Tsfahiwot Madyo v. Prison Commissioner (2017).
49. RPF 603/06 Ofer Shimon v. Israel Prison Service (2006).
50. RPF 2416/05 Anonymous (deceased) v. Israel Prison Service (2007).
51. RPF 5493/06 Emanuel Peled v. Israel Prison Service (2010).
52. RPF 8420/20 State of Israel - Israel Prison Service v. Tabari (2020).
53. CA (Crim) 255/68 State of Israel v. Ben Moshe, PD 22(2) 435 (1968).
54. CA (Crim) 1269/15 Anonymous v. State of Israel (2015).
55. HCJ 15432/03 SH.Y.N. - Equal Representation of Women v. Cable and Satellite Broadcasting Council, PD 58(3) 65 (2004).
56. CA (Civil) 2260/08 (Tel Aviv District) Angel Shalgin., et al. v. Israel Prison Service (2008).
57. Foreign Case Law.
58. Dennis Andrew Nilsen v. United Kingdom, ECHR 470 (2010).
59. Mellor v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, EWCA 472 (2001).
60. Ramirez v. Pugh, 379 F.3d 122 (3d Cir. 2004).
61. Raymond v. Honey, AC 1, 10G (1983).
62. Roth v. United States, 354 U.S. 476, 485 (1957).